In 1971 Bowie released "Hunky Dory", possibly
his most personal album. Half the songs were dedicated to people that he loved
or admired: his newborn son (Kooks), his mentally ill brother (The Bewlay
Brothers), Bob Dylan (Song For Bob Dylan), Andy Warhol (Andy Warhol), Lou Reed
(Queen Bitch) and the other half were inspired by deeply personal feelings,
including the majestic Life On Mars?. His public self was almost fully formed -
and about to take over from his private self for a few years. This brought him
to a pinnacle of fame, but almost killed him. He became addicted to drugs and
had paranoid episodes. He would eventually "kill" all of his public
personas and resume rigid control of his private life, which became pointedly
obvious during the last 12 years.
The song that opened the album, "Changes",
would telegraph his intentions to the world: he was ready to take big risks
("turn and face the strange") and nothing would be the same anymore.
In less than a year from then, he had announced to the "Melody Maker"
that he was gay, created the Ziggy Stardust persona and same-titled seminal
album and famously appeared on Top Of The Pops perforning "Starman"
with the Spiders From Mars, a flamboyant, multicolored creature in a a
flamboyant, multicolored costume. He owned the stage, flirted with the camera
and flirted with his guitarist, causing jaws to drop all through the nation,
but not in shock and disgust, more like in shock and admiration. A superstar
was born.
Changes for Bowie, however, meant an endless stream of
them in rapid succesion: while people were still struggling to get their heads
around the idea of his gayness, he was already telegraphing new facts through
his songs. Years before his "I'm not gay, I'm actually bisexual"
"Playboy" interview, it was already made clear in two songs in 1972.
"John, I'm Only Dancing" was recorded right
after the "Ziggy Stardust" album, the watershed moment of Bowie's
career and the definitive album of the Glam Rock movement. It was his follow-up
single to "Starman" and it was a hit in the UK, although it was not
released in the US, being judged too risqué. It's the timid apology of the singer
to his lover: "John, I'm only dancing, she turns me on, don't get me
wrong, I'm only dancing". He even equivocally states his love to him.
" Oh shadow love was quick and clean, life's a well-thumbed machine. I saw
you watching from the stairs, you're everyone that ever cared. Oh lordy, oh
lordy, you know I need some loving. Move me, touch me."
In 1974, a completely reworked funky-dance version was
recorded in the US, called "John, I’m Only Dancing (Again)", which
drops the gay content of the original. Perhaps David meant to release it in the
US market, where the "gay stuff" did not fly. The US success of his
singles "Young Americans" and especially "Fame", made the
release of JIODA redundant. It was finally released in 1979 in the UK and
reached the same chart position as the original version.
the original:
It was a track from "Ziggy Stardust" called
"Suffragette City" that took things to the next stage: this time
there was no timid apology. "Hey man, ah leave me alone you know... This
mellow thighed chick just put my spine out of place" he sings and to make
things perfectly clear, he adds "There's only room for one and here she
comes, here she comes". Not that romance is involved: he clarifies this
with "wham bam thank ya ma'am!". The metamorphosis is complete,
however: without much fanfare, Bowie is now a bisexual entering his
heterosexual phase.
original lyrics version:
Live in Austin, Tx, 1990:
Lady Stardust is another great song. The lyrics go:
"People stared at the makeup on his face. Laughed at his long black hair,
his animal grace. The boy in the bright blue jeans jumped up on the stage and
Lady Stardust sang his songs of darkness and disgrace". The 2nd verse goes
"I smiled sadly for a love I could not obey. Lady Stardust sang his songs
of darkness and dismay." It closes with "Oh how I sighed when they
asked if I knew his name!" The song was reportedly written for Marc Bolan.
In the title track, Ziggy Stardust, we're introduced to the incredible alien who fell to Earth to charm us into submission: naturally, he became a Pop Idol. Plus we get snippets of his physical description: "He came on so loaded man, well hung and snow white tan". And later: "He was the naz (= gorgeous), with God given ass. He took it all too far, but boy, could he play guitar!"
The song was later successfully covered by 80s Goth
band Bauhaus.
The opening song is called Five Years and it's about
announcing to the world that the Earth would be gone in 5 years. It contains
the line: "A cop knelt and kissed the feet of a priest and a queer threw
up at the sight of that."
This is a mesmerizing performance (watch his face!)
from the Dinah Shore Chevy Show in 1975:
The fantastic rocker Moonage Daydream contains the
lines: I'm the space invader, I'll be a rock'n'rolling bitch for you" and
later: "the church of man love is such a holy place to be. Make me know
you really care, make me jump into the air."
The epic closer of the album is called Rock'n'Roll
Suicide: "You're too old to lose it, too young to choose it and the clock
waits so patiently on your song. You walk past a cafe but you don't eat when
you've lived too long. Oh, no, no, no, you're a rock'n'roll suicide." But
all this doom and gloom is dissipated in the end by these lyrics: "Oh no
love! You're not alone. You're watching yourself but you're too unfair. You got
your head all tangled up but if I could only make you care" and it closes
with the repeated phrase; "you're wonderful give me your hands!" A simple
but effective message: You're Not Alone.
I think you can tell by now that "Ziggy
Stardust" is one of my favorite albums of all-time. Just two points to get
the full effect: a. listen to the songs in the original sequence and b. as Bowie
himself often marked on the album covers of that era: "to be played at
maximum volume."
Another question for you - what did you think of Streisand's cover of Life On Mars? I remember reading one review after another excoriating her for even attempting the song and how she obviously had no clue as to what Bowie was saying. Since I wasn't that into Bowie at the time, I had no problem with her version and liked the bombast. You may have an entirely different take on the matter?
ReplyDeleteI was already madly in love with the DB original when I first heard the BS version, RM, but I still liked it. Her bombast actually fits the song. Can't compare to the original, but it's good nevertheless. Teenager Lorde did a decent job of it at this year's Brit Awards as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQX-3mbwvSo
ReplyDelete