While
the Beatles heralded the commencement of the Summer of Love with the opening
bars of Sgt. Pepper's and laid down the law with All You Need Is Love
("there's nothing you can do that can't be done: it's easy"), it was
the Stones that gave us the bad news of the utopia's death. And the obituary
read: "Rape, murder! It's just a shot away!"
In
a moment of inspiration and serendipity, the above line, which Jagger felt he
couldn't sing and which was initially intended for Bonnie Bramlett, who was
unavailable, was given to New Orleans-born Merry Clayton, who was summoned at a
last-minute late-night recording session during the mixing phase, arranged by
her friend and record producer Jack Nitzsche. She seized the opportunity,
wailing, "Rape, murder! It's just a shot away!" like the end times
were nigh. It was more than fitting that this line be sung by a person most
vulnerable to the threat of violence expressed by the lyric, both because of
her gender, as well as because of her race.
"That's
a kind of end-of-the-world song, really. It's apocalypse; the whole record's
like that," Jagger told Rolling Stone in 1995, describing Gimme Shelter. Like
nothing else in Rock & Roll, the song embodies the physical experience of
living through a tumultuous historical moment. It's the Stones' perfect storm:
the ultimate Sixties eulogy and Rock's greatest bad-trip anthem, with the
gathering power of Soul music and a chaotic drive to beat any Punk Rock. The
song was born during a pounding English rainstorm. "It was just a terrible
f*cking day," Richards recalled. He was killing time in the apartment of
English art-scene guru Robert Fraser while girlfriend Anita Pallenberg was on
set making Performance, a film in which she beds down with Jagger. With chords
ghosted by a droning E-note, the music radiated dread – clearly inspired by a
mix of Jimmy Reed's trance-inducing blues, Richards' own romantic anxiety, and heroin,
which he'd just begun using. It took him about 20 minutes or so to get down the
basics, which were fleshed out over several sessions in London and Los Angeles
during 1969. The finished version is something entirely new for the Stones,
with a slithering Watts-Wyman groove and full gospel-style backing vocals. When
the band played the song at Altamont, minutes before concertgoer Meredith
Hunter was stabbed, the lines seemed like grim prophecy. Richards later said
that his guitar fell apart during the recording, "as if by design."
Gimme
Shelter (our song at #3, which is upwardly mobile in my list: it may as well be
#1 in a couple of years) first
appeared as the opening track on the band's 1969 album Let It Bleed. Although
the first word was spelled "Gimmie" on that album, subsequent
recordings by the band and other musicians have made "Gimme" the
customary spelling. Greil Marcus, writing in Rolling Stone magazine at the time
of its release, said of it, "The Stones have never done anything
better." It's definitely Keith's finest hour.
This
version was filmed live at the Trans World Dome, St Louis, Missouri, on
December 12 1997:
The
original backing singer, Merry Clayton, recorded her own version in 1970 which
entered the Billboard Hot 100, peaking at #73.
Grand
Funk Railroad covered the song on the album Survival in 1971; it was a #61 US
single.
Patti
Smith released the song as a single from her April 2007 covers album Twelve.
At
#2 there's a song that was not recorded for their 1967 album Their Satanic Majesties
Request as would seem befitting, but was instead the opening track on their
1968 album Beggars Banquet. Rolling Stone magazine placed it at #32 in their
list of the 500 Greatest Songs of All Time.
Jagger
stated that his influence for the song came from Baudelaire and from the
Russian author Mikhail Bulgakov's novel The Master and Margarita (which had
just appeared in English translation in 1967). The book was given to him by
Marianne Faithfull.
No
band ever summed up its mission on Earth as perfectly as the Stones did here.
Sympathy for the Devil was a shot at their critics that also mirrored
real-world evil. (Jagger had to change the lyric "who killed Kennedy"
to "who killed the Kennedys" when news of Robert F. Kennedy's
assassination reached the Beggars Banquet sessions in June 1968.) Originally
written as a Dylan-esque folk song, it rolls forward like a storm front, driven
by a menacing samba-funk groove from Watts and African percussionist Rocky
Dijon and piano and bass (played by Richards), with a wicked guitar solo midway
through. The unrepentant whoo-whoo backing vocals were sung by a crowd that
included Watts, Jones (who would be dead in a year) and his ex-girlfriend Anita
Pallenberg, who was keeping company with Richards. Mick Jagger made the role of
the devil his own.
Here
they are live at Zilker Park, Austin, Texas, 22nd October 2006.
Guns
N' Roses recorded a cover in 1994 which reached #55 on the Billboard Hot 100;
it was featured in the closing credits of Neil Jordan's film adaptation of Anne
Rice's Interview with the Vampire.
My
#1 song is You Can't Always Get What You Want. Although it was the closing
track, it was the first song recorded for the album Let It Bleed (1969). So the opening track of the album is my #3 and the
closing track is my #1. That's a good track record for an album, isn't it? The
song was also named as the 100th greatest song of all time by Rolling Stone
magazine.
It
captivated me when I first heard it: the choral introduction got to me first,
then the wonderful arrangement and production and finally the complex lyrics.
It
was the shotgun lesson of that decade and the Stones delivered it with
bittersweet flair: Everything was possible, and it all came at a price. They
were at a new creative peak and preparing to return to the road. But Richards
was using heroin; Jagger's girlfriend, Marianne Faithfull, had suffered a
miscarriage; and Jones was all but gone. You Can't Always Get What You Want was
"basically all Mick," Richards admitted. The singer turned that
turmoil into a witty evocation of universal disillusionment countered by the
practical hope in the chorus and a sumptuous R&B arrangement: the entrance
of the London Bach Choir, arranged by Jack Nitzsche; guest pianist Al Kooper's
regal contribution on French horn; and the pushing shuffle in the drums, played
by producer Jimmy Miller. "It was," Richards crowed, "a
beautiful juxtaposition" – just like the Sixties. If Gimme Shelter brought
fear to your soul for what was to come, You Can't Always Get What You Want
brought sadness for what was no more.
This
is live at Twickenham Stadium, London, August 2003:
The
song was also used very creatively in the funeral scene from The Big Chill
(1983):
Blues
musician Luther Allison covered the song for the 1997 tribute album Paint It
Blue: Songs of the Rolling Stones.
Band
from TV, a
charity cover band whose members are all actors from American television series,
covered it for the soundtrack of House.
Now, let's move on to this week's statistics. This
week's was thematically different, as it was almost exclusively devoted to the
Rolling Stones. It also had one of those rare days that went by without a new
post, plus a day of old relatively obscure songs, which predictably didn't
receive many visits. The Rolling Stones commanded a strong readership interest
however.
As for our visitors' weekly Top 10, behind our usual
suspects, the US and Greece, we find the UK which had another great week and
comfortably sits at #3. France also had a good week and returns to #4. It was
also a stellar week for the
Netherlands, which occupy the 5th position. Russia
continues to be on a downward spiral and is not even in the Top 10 this week. We
do have a new entry, this time it's Sweden, also a re-entry, which belongs to
Canada. A most hearty welcome!
The
full Top 10 is as follows:
1.
the United States
2.
Greece
3.
the United Kingdom
4.
France
5.
the Netherlands
6.
Germany
7.
Cyprus
8.
Ukraine
9.
Sweden
10.
Canada
Here
are the other countries that graced us with their presence this week
(alphabetically): Afghanistan, Argentina, Australia, Belgium, Brazil, Chile,
China, Colombia, Hong Kong, India, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Malaysia, Peru, Philippines,
Poland, Portugal, Romania, Russia, Saudi Arabia, Spain, Switzerland, Thailand, Turkey,
Tunesia, the United Arab Emirates, and Zimbabwe. Happy to have you all!
Here's
the all-time list.
1.
the United States = 46.7%
2.
Greece = 18.8%
3.
Russia = 9.5%
4.
Germany = 3.6%
5.
France = 2.6%
6.
the United Kingdom = 2.4%
7.
Canada = 1.07%
8.
Ireland = 1.02%
9.
Cyprus = 0.89%
10.
Italy = 0.61%
As
a bonus, I went and found an interactive map, where all the countries that have
visited the blog so far are in blue (as you can see, that's most of the map!).
Here it is, for your discerning eyes:
That's all for today, folks. Till the next one!
Great list! I could make a case for a couple of more entries, but I can't fault your top 10. However, one of my all-time favorite movie moments came when Mick sang "Memo from Turner" in "Performance." It may not be a Rolling Stones song proper, but it's credited to Jagger/Richards and the band has performed it.
ReplyDeleteThanks AFHI! I do agree that Mick's rendition of Memo From Turner was one of the high moments of Performance. Director Nicolas Roeg was good working with Pop Stars. His collaborations include Mick Jagger in Performance, David Bowie in The Man Who Fell to Earth and Art Garfunkel in Bad Timing. In all three cases, he brought out the best in them.
DeleteThe last three songs to grace your list are as good as any to receive top honors so well done sir. As I promised, these are my top ten Rolling Stones songs:
ReplyDelete10) Let's Spend The Night Together. Great rollicking 60s rock that still packs a punch. I love Ruby Tuesday, too but I had to make a choice and the naughty one won out. Appropos for this group.
9) Under My Thumb. Love the marimba vibe and again, bad boy persona they were stoking in counterpoint to the Beatles' early nice guys image.
8) Dandelion. I love a good pop song and this fits the bill. The psychedelic aspects only enhanced the whole effect. There was a Beatles-esque flavor to the proceedings that was rare for them.
7) Over the years, I grew weary of this tune no doubt due to over-exposure but when I hear it now, I'm transported back to '65 and memories of all the great Rock & Roll that year produced. Iconic as all get out and one ripping good opening.
6) Jumping Jack Flash. After the psychedelia of Satanic Majesties this was a welcome return to basic rock & roll the band did so well. It even merited a mention in one of your favorite songs American Pie.
5) Honky Tonk Women. Only the Stones could get away with bringing a song about hookers and floozies to the top of the American charts. And it has another great opening blast of music that gets everyone up on their feet.
4) Brown Sugar. Another hit, another great iconic opening that signals a good time will be had by all. And again, only the Stones could top the charts with lines like "Hear him whip the women just around midnight". Pure rock bliss.
3) Gimme Shelter. The grandeur of this song is matched by it's apocalyptic ferocity and as much as I loved their music before, this one served notice to the world that the boys were now men.
2) She's A Rainbow. What I said about Dandelion goes double for this baroque pop song that was so in the moment in '67. It could very easily have been my #1 if not for...well, I'll get to that in a moment. Love the piano, the groovy strings, the almost comical background vocals "Ooh la, la, Ooh la, la, la la" and the pink psychedelic picture sleeve that was my pride and joy until someone stole it when I foolishly brought it to school. She comes in color!
1) You Can't Always Get What You Want. Well, looky here! Everything you said to describe this masterpiece is spot on. Most acts would be hard-pressed to deliver a song of this caliber yet the Stones managed two on Let It Bleed. I think the musical journey this takes us on gives it the edge over Gimme Shelter but really, they are both genuine, Grade A examples of how a rock song can transcend it's mere pop reputation to become an important and worthy piece of art.
Well, that's it. Thanks for taking us on this journey and I look forward to whatever future musical trips you choose to take us on.
This is a great list, RM, and exquisitely presented! I see that 5 of your songs are in my Top 10 too, HTW is at my #14 and 3 more are in my positions 21-30. All 9 are graded A and A-. I only missed out on Dandelion, it's a great Pop song, but, to be honest, it's been a long time since I've listened to it and, like AFHI's suggestion Memo From Turner, it kinda fell through the cracks. Thanks ever so much for taking the time to compile your list and share it with us.
DeleteYeah, I was rather surprised you couldn't find a spot in 75 songs for Dandelion but I guess nobody's perfect, eh?
ReplyDeleteTrue that. :)
Delete